Spanish is the only world language left at Carmel Middle School after the Carmel Unified School District dropped French there and eliminated Chinese across all schools for the 2026-27 year.

The cuts, made during the second semester of the 2025-26 school year, ended a French program offered at the middle school for more than 40 years, The Sandpiper first reported. The district cited declining enrollment. Chinese, added in 2007, was phased out over two years.

Carmel Middle School Principal Daniel Morgan told The Sandpiper that French 1 had just 13 students in 2025-26, down from 23 the year before. Only six or seven students signed up for French 1 for 2026-27, he said. With those numbers, he said the school could not justify running the program.

Morgan said French 1 will stay on the elective selection sheet. If interest rises, the school will approach the district about restoring the class for 2027-28.

Five-year program, four-year window

Carmel High School still offers five levels of French, through AP. But counselor Jeff Rogers told The Sandpiper the language program spans five years. "So if we don't start it in eighth-grade, students can't complete AP," he said.

Six Carmel Middle School eighth-graders are riding the bus to Carmel High School each day to take French 2 during first period, The Sandpiper reported. French teacher Suzanne Marden, set to retire in June, said at a May board meeting that eliminating French at the middle school has long-term consequences for the high school program. She suggested expanding the busing arrangement to French 1 as a workaround.

Several teachers told the student newspaper the changes felt abrupt. Carmel Middle School French teacher Janine Olin, who spent last year on sabbatical studying French abroad, told The Sandpiper she learned in February that the program was being cut when she contacted the administration about returning.

That caught the community's attention. Carmel High School senior Eli David launched a Change.org petition in May to save the middle school French program. It had 260 signatures as of Nov. 1.

The district told The Sandpiper that world language information will be presented at the CUSD board meeting on Nov. 18.